Here is a look at the player ratings for Atalanta vs PSG from the big French and Italian newspapers following their Champions League quarterfinal on 12 August, 2020. PSG snatched victory thanks to goals in the 90th and 93rd minute, breaking Atalanta hearts.
L’Equipe player ratings Atalanta Paris SG 2020
French newspaper L’Equipe were very unhappy with the likes of Mauro Icardi and Pablo Sarabia, both of whom got a 2/10 player rating. Their team rating also had Atalanta as a better team in comparison to Paris Saint-Germain.

Le Parisien Paris St Germain player ratings vs Atalanta
Le Parisien were even more critical of Icardi than L’Equipe, giving the Argentine striker a 1/10 player rating. They were also not impressed with Sarabia (2/10 player rating) and Ander Herrera (3/10 player rating)